Frequently, this is in the form of written descriptions from an investigator, inperson discussions, telephone conversations, etc. Section 5 applies in both civil and criminal proceedings. These include the detection and interpretation of mixtures, ystr testing, mitochondrial dna testing, and the evidentiary implications of dna database searches of. Essential reading for lawyers, judges, and expert witnesses in dna cases, the double helix and the law of evidence is an informative and provocative contribution to the. The probative value of dna evidence has been held up as a most valuable. To protect potential evidence, crime scene personnel must know how to properly collect dna evidence, including touch dna items. Individual evidence has more probative value than class evidence. The most common form of dna analysis in criminal cases utilizes four or five single locus vntr probes to produce a multilocus genot or, more simply, a dna profile. However, probative value of proposed evidence must be weighed against prejudice in the minds of jurors toward the opposing party or criminal defendant. In every trial, where dna evidence is adduced, the court has to be alert and. It operates to exclude evidence that is logically probative and so satisfies s55 relevant evidence but insufficiently probative when considered against one or more of the following three policy concerns. The advances in touch dna recovery has complicated fingerprint development to a certain extent, as we are now. Relevance, in the common law of evidence, is the tendency of a given item of evidence to prove or disprove one of the legal elements of the case, or to have probative value to make one of the elements of the case likelier or not. Shelton found that jurors expectations had little effect on their willingness to.
In the absence of any blood or dna evidence linking him to the crime, he was acquitted on the first day of trial. In other words, the sequence or order of the dna building blocks is different in particular regions of the cell, making each persons dna unique. Increasing probative value of degraded or limited dna evidence. In this context, questions always arise as to the probative value of dna evidence given by experts in the courtroom.
In the preceding chapters, we have tried to clarify the scientific issues involved in forensic dna testing. Pdf eyewitness evidence improving its probative value. Future of dna evidence to identify ways to maximize the value of dna in our criminal justice system. The aura of infallibility conferred on crime lab analysts by csistyle tv shows exacerbates the problem when juries place undue weight on indeterminate dna evidence of little to no probative value. This paper deals with perceived obstacles and potential solutions in the evaluation of the probative value of forensic biology results, such as dna profiles 1, when the competing propositions of interest relate to activities rather than the source of the recovered trace material.
The assessment of expert evidence on dna in malaysia. Forensic dna evidence interpretation is the most comprehensive resource for dna casework available today. Dna typing in the criminaljustice system has so far been used primarily for direct comparison of dna profiles of evidence samples with profiles of samples from known suspects. Probative value and prioritization determining probative value of evidence. Although the knowledge base to understand uncertainties is growing, a challenge remains to prioritise research and to continuously assess the magnitude and consequences of misleading evidence in criminal cases. The dna typing discussed in this chapter is mainly standard singlelocus rflp typing on southern blots without apparent band shifting. Chapter 5 noted several lrs that might be used to describe the probative value of dna data. Explains technical aspects of dna profiling and how this information should. Body fluid evidence dna techniques and the impact of technological advances probative value touch dna blood seminal fluid urine vaginal secretions sexual assault.
Evidence has the potential to be misleading if its value when expressing beliefs in hypotheses is not fully understood or presented. This paper argues that there are many circumstances in which the actual probative value of evidence may be very different from what science and justice xxx 20 xxxxxx. Examples are fingerprints, handwriting, dna patterns, and sometimes physical matches, such as a piece of broken glass that fits exactly to another. How is direct evidence different from circumstantial evidence.
In a trial of a defendant for murder, the defendants dispute with his neighbor unrelated to the crime has a no probative value because it provides no relevant information to the trier of the fact. Probative value considers the evidences usefulness in proving, or disproving, a particular fact in the case, with the court determining the actual value of such evidence according to its relevance to the case at hand. Gregg laberge, scientific director and bureau commander of the denver police department crime laboratory. An empirical assessment of presentation formats for trace evidence with a relatively small random match probability dale a. This capacity is often stressed by the rising level of violent crimes. Written by leaders in the fields of biology and statistics, the book emphasizes the interpretation of test results and provides the necessary formulae in an easily accessible manner. They know its painful and believe its necessary, but haven t the foggiest idea how or why it works. A systematic analysis of misleading evidence in unsafe. When the dangers of unfair prejudice, timeconsumption, and confusion of the issues substantially outweigh the probative value of particular evidence, the trial. There is no doubt as to the probative value of a full profile dna match taken from a scene sample such as a condom or a duvet. The probative value of a mixed profile can be estimated in the absence of a poi.
Probative value considers the evidence s usefulness in proving, or disproving, a particular fact in the case, with the court determining the actual value of such evidence according to its relevance to the case at hand. Written by leaders in the fields of biology and statistics, the book emphasizes the. Understand the time and resources required from the lab to test different categories of evidence. Bridging law, genetics, and statistics, this book is an authoritative history of the long and tortuous process by which dna science has been integrated into the american legal system. Eyewitness evidence improving its probative value gary l. Because of the potential power and probative value of dna evidence, it is important to learn more about juror and judicial response to this evidence in the face of strong and weak nonstatistical evidence.
Looking to the future, kaye uses probability theory to clarify legal concepts of relevance and probative value, and describes alternatives to racebased dna profile frequencies. Probative value of forensic science conclusions should be. The probative value of dna testing has been steadily increasing as. The more lr exceeds 1, the greater the probative value of the data in supporting hypothesis s see lempert 1977. Although it appears that the results of the dna profile test are generally accepted in the relevant scientific communities, the probative value of population genetics probability must also be considered, and the trial judge must determine if the potentially prejudicial effect upon the jury exceeds the probative value of the evidence. In 1996, the national institute of justice published a book titled. Na is a powerful investigative tool because, with the exception of identical twins, no two people have the same dna.
This section applies to evidence to which objection is taken under either s 5 or s 7. Ilj to determine the role and impact of forensic evidence in the investigation of crimes and prosecution of defendants. Determining probative value and admissibility of scientific evidence judges and lawyers usually react to science with all the enthusiasm of a child about to get a tetanus shot. Under the federal rules, relevant evidence is to be excluded if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice. Generally in law, evidence that is not probative doesnt tend to prove the proposition for which it is proffered is inadmissible and the rules of evidence permit it to be excluded from a proceeding or stricken from. In a history both scientifically sophisticated and comprehensible to the nonspecialist. By one estimate, the lab handled dna evidence from at least 500 cases a. This part also addresses issues associated with identifying the hypothesis of interest and characterizing the evidence. Its use is one of the ways the prejudicial effect of evidence to which objection is taken may be overcome or at least reduced to the extent that the probative value of the evidence is no longer outweighed by the danger of its unfair prejudice s 7 or substantially outweighed by that danger s 5. Practitioner guide no 2 assessing the probative value of dna evidence guidance for judges, lawyers, forensic scientists and expert witnesses by roberto puchsolis, forensic statistician, forensic science service.
A way to increase the probative value of class evidence is to find as many. Documents such as bench books, aid judges in constructing their directions for. Dna evidence to establish innocence after trial research report. After that several states have also recognized the inherent reliability and probative value of forensic dna evidence and have passed statutes deeming it admissible in criminal prosecutions. This book is essential reading for students and practitioners of criminal law and. Instructed experts have access to the latest forensic techniques to identify dna evidence, preserve and extract samples from all manner of objects or exhibits, in accordance with industry best practice guidelines issued by the association of chief police officers acpo. However, probative value of proposed evidence must be weighed by the trial judge against prejudicing in the minds of jurors toward the opposing party or criminal defendant. As long as lr is greater than 1, the dna data support hypothesis s. The legal term probative value refers to any evidence that serves the purpose of proving something during a trial. As far as the probative value of the withheld evidence, its pretty much a bust, as the results of dna testing released in 2006 as new evidence of macdonalds innocence matched neither helena stoeckley nor her boyfriend greg mitchell.
In cases involving scientific evidence in the form of a test result linking. The reference manual on scientific evidence, third editi. Juries could be given written guidance in the form of booklets that explain dna evidence generally, for reference during the trial. Determining the probative value of evidence submitted to the laboratory begins. Increasing the probative value of degraded or limited dna evidence by combining two or more dna technologies. Use of dna information in the legal system dna technology in. The problems with dna evidence and testing the atlantic.
Probative value definition, examples, cases, processes. This chapter provides an overview of how dna evidence might be used in the investigation and prosecution of crimes and in civil litigation. Dna testing is a valid probative tool in the philippines. Eyewitness testimony is a form of direct evidence which may be regarded as valuable for the forensic purposes. Eyewitness evidence improving its probative value article pdf available in psychological science in the public interest 72 november 2006 with 1,215 reads how we measure reads. Having the effect of proof, tending to prove, or actually proving.
The book covers the full range of criminal casework and also. The double helix and the law of evidence by david h. Dna has become a very important compliment to fingerprints, as are all advances in the forensic field. However, that application constitutes only the tip of the iceberg of potential lawenforcement applications. Probative is a term used in law to signify tending to prove. Dna evidence in the legal system the evaluation of.
Expected evidential efficiency summarises the probative value. The value of dna evidence office for victims of crime. More questions about real and demonstrative evidence. Combining dna data from all technologies for example partial nuclear dna profile, ystr profile and mitochondrial dna profile in case of degraded samples to increase the probative value of final dna test report. What aspects of forensic science have the most probative value, and why. In this monograph, we do not discuss the mechanisms responsible for distortions in information retrieved in eyewitness interviews. The importance of scientific evaluation of biological.
A typical dispute arises when the prosecutor wishes to introduce the previous conduct of a. One key element for the admission of evidence is whether. The risk of an adventitious match is obtained on a per case basis. Forensic dna evidence interpretation explains and discusses methods to evaluate the evidential value of dna profiles used for identifying persons in a forensic.
In a trial of a defendant for murder, the defendants dispute with his neighbor unrelated to the crime has a no probative value because it provides no. Despite a strong attack from the defense and its experts, the court found that the dna evidence was highly reliable and that its probative value outweighed the. I have written many times before about the potential problems when using the likelihood ratio lr as a measure of probative value of evidence. The dna evidence process started when the police collected the physical evidence. Practitioner guide no 2 assessing the probative value of dna evidence guidance for judges, lawyers, forensic scientists and expert witnesses by roberto puchsolis, forensic statistician, forensic science service paul roberts, professor of criminal jurisprudence, university of nottingham susan pope, principal dna scientist, forensic science service. An expected range of likelihood ratios is obtained for the unknown contributors. In the last ten years, however, dna technology has. Excessive testing contributes to illinois dna backlog experts say police and prosecutors are not using discretion when submitting dna evidence for testing, and illinois. The allure of dna evidence is its capability of being presented almost exclusively in the form of numerical statistics. Part i of this paper discusses the issue of what the frequencies associated with dna evidence do and do not mean. Dna testing has become an established part of criminal justice process, and the.
Dna evidence in the legal system the evaluation of forensic. The supreme court admitted the procedures and the interpretation of dna evidence presented at the regional trial court, and highlighted the utility of dna evidence, when properly collected, handled and stored, to assist in the prompt and fair resolution of cases. The evidentiary and probative value of dna profiling is reliant on the fact that the. Probative value and prioritization law enforcement responsibilities at the scene, cont. This is generally admissible evidence in the same way as fingerprint evidence. Courts concerned with the reliability of dna evidence often excluded it. Probative value legal definition of probative value. Practical guidance for judges, lawyers, forensic scientists and expert witnesses on the logical analysis of dna profiles, and their probative value in criminal proceedings. The national commission on the future of dna evidence was created in 1998. This report provides the results of a major study conducted by the institute for law and justice, inc. If dna profiles of samples from a population were stored in computer databanks databases, dna typing could. Part ii describes an alternate way of presenting dna statistics in court based on bayesian likelihood ratios.
Generally in law, evidence that is not probative doesnt. Forensic dna databanks and privacy of information dna. Instead, we use one example of a procedure that arose as a result of a direct request from the police to improve the probative value of eyewitness evidence. All courts are governed by rules of evidence that describe what types of evidence are admissible. The problems are especially acute when the evidence consists of a tiny sample of dna for which there are at least two people contributing often referred to as a low template mixed dna profile. Oct 04, 2015 the legal term probative value refers to any evidence that serves the purpose of proving something during a trial.
Determining the probative value of evidence submitted to the laboratory begins with case details. Master of laws at the university of south africa supervisor. Determining probative value of evidence determining the probative value of evidence submitted to the laboratory begins with case details. When the motion is filed with the court requesting testing and analysis of. Nrc ii report, there are alternative methods for assessing the probative value of dna evi. Similarly, federal rule 403 allows for exclusion to avoid substantial danger of undue prejudice. Kaye weaves together molecular biology, population genetics, the legal rules of evidence, and theories of. Identify the probative value of evidence and prioritize dna evidence. Probative value and prioritization introduction overview law enforcement responsibilities at the scene law enforcement responsibilities at the scene, cont.
Read chapter reference guide on dna identification evidencedavid h. The role and impact of forensic evidence in the criminal. It focuses on questions of statistics, probability, and population genetics. In the early years of dna testing, the testing provided some narrowing of suspects, but often yielded erroneous results. Discuss the main types of forensic evidence motive, eyewitness accounts, physical and trace evidence and the probative value of each. Touch dna is defined as the body fluids or epithelial cells left behind on an object when it is handled by a suspect. The barrister magazine admissibility of dna evidence. When a legal controversy goes to trial, the parties seek to prove their cases by the introduction of evidence.
Nov 29, 2004 forensic dna evidence interpretation is the most comprehensive resource for dna casework available today. In addition, it illuminates the workings of a theory of probative value and inductive proof that evide scholars have been propounding for some time. Interact more efficiently with crime laboratories to set expectations and manage caseloads. Agencies and laboratories have a finite capacity for processing crime scene evidence. Prioritizing evidence at the scene identifying potential dna evidence dna for law enforcement prioritizing evidence in the laboratory.
315 1140 1057 810 366 234 596 430 76 1559 1274 936 905 361 1473 421 1255 1514 184 805 1086 1558 325 1460 183 1379 780 935 3 206 869 1069 752 892 577 887 555 153 1490 989 412 213 630